Besides vs. except

 

Q:

Do you have any suggestions on a clear way to teach the difference in usage between besides and except?

Danielle Somai-Ho
somaiho@hawaii.edu


A:

With one meaning for besides, and another for except, it is easy to show a difference between these two words:

Besides (alternatively given as "beside" in some dictionaries) as a preposition means "in addition to, or "plus":

(a)

Besides "a," "e," "i," "o," and "u," the English alphabet often uses "y" as a vowel, as in "early" and "myself."

(b)

Florida has several industries besides tourism — citrus, cattle, and the Space Coast, for example.

(c)

Candidates need to demonstrate other qualities besides intelligence; they need to be compassionate and restrained, too.

Except as a preposition means with exclusion, rejection, or exception; everything other than; it carries the meaning of "minus":

(d)

Brazil borders on every country in South America except Chile and Ecuador.

(e)

The stores in the mall are open every day except on national holidays.

(f)

A year — except those divisible by 4, such as 1996 and 2000 — has 365 days.

There is no trouble keeping these clear distinctions between besides and except.

There are other meanings, however, for besides and except, which can make these words problematic.

More …